Compare Medicines
Compare two medicines side-by-side: halal status, inactive ingredients that differ, and pharmacist questions — free, cited, and private.
Citracal + D3 Calcium Citrate 600 mg / 1000 IU Tablet
- Form
- Tablet (film-coated) · 600 mg calcium + 1000 IU D3
- Market
- US
- Confidence
- Medium
- Microcrystalline Cellulose Looks Halal
- Croscarmellose Sodium Looks Halal
- Magnesium Stearate Uncertain
- Hypromellose (HPMC) Looks Halal
- Polysorbate 80 Uncertain
- Titanium Dioxide Looks Halal
- Vitamin D3 (Cholecalciferol) Uncertain
Tums Antacid (Calcium Carbonate 500 mg)
- Form
- Chewable tablet · 500 mg
- Market
- US
- Confidence
- Medium
- Sucrose Looks Halal
- Starch (Maize/Potato) Looks Halal
- Talc Looks Halal
- Magnesium Stearate Uncertain
Comparison summary
Citracal + D3 Calcium Citrate 600 mg / 1000 IU Tablet is Uncertain with Medium confidence. Tums Antacid (Calcium Carbonate 500 mg) is Uncertain with Medium confidence. They share 1 inactive ingredients in our database and differ on 9 others.
Cleaner halal profile in this pair: Tums Antacid (Calcium Carbonate 500 mg) (uncertain) — confirm equivalence and dosing with your clinician before switching.
Inactive ingredient differences
1 shared · 6 only in Citracal + D3 Calcium Citrate 600 mg / 1000 IU Tablet · 3 only in Tums Antacid (Calcium Carbonate 500 mg)
Only in Citracal + D3 Calcium Citrate 600 mg / 1000 IU Tablet
Only in Tums Antacid (Calcium Carbonate 500 mg)
Shared ingredients (1) appear in both products — open each medicine report for the full list.
Questions about this comparison
- How do Citracal + D3 Calcium Citrate 600 mg / 1000 IU Tablet and Tums Antacid (Calcium Carbonate 500 mg) compare for halal status?
- Citracal + D3 Calcium Citrate 600 mg / 1000 IU Tablet: Uncertain (Medium confidence). Tums Antacid (Calcium Carbonate 500 mg): Uncertain (Medium confidence). RxHalal does not issue religious rulings — use this to ask your pharmacist about sources.
- Which inactive ingredients differ between these two medicines?
- Only in Citracal + D3 Calcium Citrate 600 mg / 1000 IU Tablet: Microcrystalline Cellulose, Croscarmellose Sodium, Hypromellose (HPMC), Polysorbate 80, Titanium Dioxide, Vitamin D3 (Cholecalciferol). Only in Tums Antacid (Calcium Carbonate 500 mg): Sucrose, Starch (Maize/Potato), Talc. Shared: 1 ingredients.
- What should I ask my pharmacist when comparing these medicines?
- Is the magnesium stearate in this product plant-derived? Can you confirm the source with the manufacturer? What is the source of the fatty acids?
- Is Tums Antacid (Calcium Carbonate 500 mg) a halal-friendlier option than Citracal + D3 Calcium Citrate 600 mg / 1000 IU Tablet?
- In our database, Tums Antacid (Calcium Carbonate 500 mg) ranks cleaner (Fewer flagged excipients (1 vs 4).). Confirm equivalence and dosing with your clinician — not a fatwa.
Clinician-friendly share summary
A neutral 6–10 line summary you can paste into a message or print.